jump to navigation

How Roman Catholicism Can Save Itself April 16, 2010

Posted by Mary W. Matthews in Religion & Theology.

I am no fan of Roman Catholicism. Here are a few of the many reasons why:

  • Jesus of Nazareth preached direct access to God; the Magisterium says you can only get to God through the intermediation of the Magisterium.
  • Jesus was “first among equals,” and not above doing the jobs of a house slave; the Magisterium’s power structure resembles that of the Roman Empire: emperor/pope; senator/cardinal; centurion/bishop, and so on down to the lowly soldier/priest. And whoa, check out the luxury the pope and higher-ups allow themselves!
  • Jesus welcomed women into his company; traveled with them; taught them as disciples; and chose them as apostles. The Magisterium denies these facts, denies that Genesis 1:27 and 5:1-2 are true, and treats women as subhuman creatures who are evil from the waist down.
  • Jesus loved children. A small but significant fraction of Roman Catholic priests “loves” children. Hundreds and possibly thousands of young lives have been ruined or scarred. Over the course of at least the last 50 years, the Magisterium has been far more likely to protect felonious priests than it is to protect OR succor their victims.

The current crisis in Roman Catholicism grieves me, and the reaction of the Magisterium appalls me. Decade on decade of felonies come to light, and the Church blames the media, especially the New York Times? Decade on decade of higher-ups covering up felonies, and somehow both the felonies and the cover-ups are the fault of liberal Protestants, gays, Jews — Anybody But Us?

From my viewpoint, the Magisterium has lost its moral authority and does not yet understand this. “Bless me, Father, for I have sinned. It has been two days since the most recent facts came to light about priests committing child abuse and bishops, cardinals, and popes aiding and abetting them.” Or, worse, “Bless me Father, for I have sinned. It has been two days since you raped a child.” I don’t want your blessing, Father. I want your wallet, keys, and belt as you are hauled away to prison.

If the Magisterium wants to save its power and privilege, its stranglehold over the spiritual lives of hundreds of millions, the pope MUST take this crisis onto himself. The pope must very publicly repent, and not just for his own sins in preferring to protect felonious priests over protecting victimized children. The pope must repent for the structures of the Church that led to, enabled, and covered up these terrible crimes. Indeed, the pope must repent for the crimes themselves: he must take on “the sins of the world” — of his world, of a world that imagines being ordained means being magically transformed into a better human being than the non-ordained.

Second, the pope must require every male member of the Roman Catholic hierarchy to perform the same repentance and atonement. Both felons and those who aided and abetted them must be handed over to secular authorities for civil justice.

Third, the pope must call Vatican III to address the structural flaws in Roman Catholicism that made these felonies possible. God blessed sex and called it good, so why is sex evil except for procreation? And why are women evil for compelling men to think about sex?

The pope ought to go to those nuns he’s been harassing for being too uppity, repent to THEM, and submit the entire Magisterium to their judgment.

This is how I think Roman Catholic Magisterium might be able to save itself. It’s not going to happen, of course. Even after this crisis began, the pope has continued ordaining and promoting Opus Dei priests; Opus Dei is the most elitist, misogynistic, reactionary organization in Roman Catholicism.

The poet T.S. Eliot predicted the world would end “not with a bang, but a whimper.” My prediction is that Roman Catholicism will end with a priest’s “bang” and a child’s whimper.



1. lynx - April 16, 2010

not just the Male clergy need to repent, if you’d read the horror stories coming out of Ireland you’d know that priests and nuns alike not only raped thousands of children but beat literally thousands more to death over the course of several decades. And that’s before you get into the workhouses run by the nuns for “fallen women” that kept literally thousands of women locked up inside convents as slave labor over the course of decades.

The Roman catholic church is beyond any hope of reform or redemption.

2. Rohit - April 17, 2010

You are suggesting a massive change of policies for the Pope. No doubt that implementing them would be the right way to begin solving this situation.
But change is very hard to implement. I think the present Pope will prefer to go about handling things the orthodox way of just mediation & prayer …& leave such changes to his successor…that gives us how much…10 years more? :/

3. Michael - April 17, 2010

I have to agree with lynx, and with the entire spirit and substance of your blog entry. I fear that ‘moral authority’ is inherently an oxymoron – certainly it is when applied to the Church, and to just about any organized religion. Marx was correct when he wrote, “Die Religion … ist das Opium des Volkes” – religion is the opium of the people. The quote is usually mis-translated as ‘the masses.’ In any case, I prefer the original German: Die Religion.

4. facts - April 17, 2010

I agree. The church has gone into the toilet.

5. Ugly Bug - April 17, 2010

Please remember that the Catholic Church is NOT just the bishops, cardinals and the pope. The Church is millions of ordinary people who are not guilty of any crimes. People who feel terrible about these scandals. People who want justice for the victims of these crimes.

mothermary44 - April 17, 2010

You are quite right, Ugly Bug. And hundreds of thousands of Roman Catholic priests are not only innocent of any crimes, they are good men who are sincerely devoted to God as they understand God to be. My objection is to men who think ONLY men are made in God’s image. My objection is to men who think ordination makes them better than you and me and gives them carte blanche to commit or cover up any crime.

6. Vivian - April 17, 2010

I agree with a lot of what you’re saying, Mary. As a Roman Catholic myself, I am very embarrassed that all of these things have happened in the Vatican, but of course it wasn’t my choice to get baptized when I was 1 year old. Something that definitely goes against my Roman Catholic teachings is my belief that if you follow Jesus’s teachings directly, you will be recognized as a good person in God’s eyes. Growing up in the Catholic church, I’ve learned to appreciate the structure of this denomination, but on the flip side, there are a lot of dark corners that must be turned over to the Light.

mothermary44 - April 17, 2010

IMNSHO, you are right and the Magisterium is wrong: If you love God with all your heart and soul and mind and strength, and you love God’s creation as much as you love yourself, it doesn’t matter whether you’re Roman Catholic, Protestant, Buddhist, Confucian, Hindu, Jewish, or “other.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: